PART 1 OF 2
=========================================
Hi everyone.
Boyan Hristov wrote:
>Since BB changed the amplification tube circuits with transistor ones, the >path of getting that sound starts there. The organ will then sound >differently and I would recalibrate the tone generator to the levels at amp >output as in the B3 service manual which is readily available.
A member of the Hammond Zeni forum who used to own a red mylar capped Bill Beer chop organ until it died, and who still has the Bill Beer high power Leslies told me that he spoke to Bill Beer and Bill Beer told him that his goal with the solid state organ preamp and his high power solid state biamped Leslies with the JBL E140 bass speaker and the JBL 2482 treble driver was to create the sound of a good sounding organ and the tonality of a stock Leslie 122 but at much higher volume levels.
Bill Beer connected a frequency response meter near the Leslie, and he then set the TG recalibration to produce a similar response through the high power solid state Leslie as what was produced through a stock Leslie 122.
Bill Beer also said that he did not like a too trebly sound, instead he preferred a warmer sounding tonality.
Of course in reality the Bill Beer organs and Leslies do not actually sound identical to a stock organ and Leslie 122, instead they have a particular different tonality with a thicker sounding midrange which is a distinctive tonal characteristic of the JBL 2482 driver, for example Jim Pugh's red mylar capped Bill Beer chop organ and Bill Beer Leslie in this youtube clip of the Robert Cray band performing "The one in the middle"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frA3W6_Nxic
Wes wrote:
>Boyan - interesting hypothesis - that may be, in fact, how Bill arrived at >his calibration scheme. Or he may have created his own version of the >chart, by measuring an organ he felt was particularly balls.
Bill Beer mentioned in a 1991 Keyboard magazine interview that he measured the TG output curves of "six hot bitchin B3's" and that he used this as the basis for his "fat and ballsy" sounding TG output curve.
Bill Beer also mentioned that some of the later era Hammond organs did not sound as good because of their TG calibration which produced a more shrill sound.
Interestingly, as can be seen in my TG data spreadsheet which contains the measured TG output levels of over one hundred Hammond tone wheel organs spanning from all decades of production, the tonewheel generators of the pre 1956 Hammond organs were calibrated with noticeably higher output levels for the complex waveform pedal bass TG notes 1 to 12, and that the sine wave TG notes 13 to approximately 40 were calibrated slightly louder than that of the post 1956 organs.
The Hammond chief engineer Alan Young mentioned that the TG output curve was changed in 1956 "for the convenience of our test procedures".
The measured TG output curves of the pre 1956 and the post 1956 organs verify that there was a reduction to the output levels of the low frequency TG notes introduced in 1956.
Without actually having access to Bill Beer's TG output curves of the "six hot bitchin B3's", the following is my pure speculation, but with all this in mind, my speculation is that the "six hot bitchin B3s" that Bill Beer measured might possibly have been pre 1956 organs with the stronger output levels of the low frequency TG notes.
The only measured Bill Beer TG output curve in my TG data spreadsheet is that of a wax capped post 1956 B3 or C3 chop organ which was once owned by the Progressive Rock band Kansas.
In this Bill Beer organ, there are slightly louder than normal levels in the TG notes 13 to 31 range, but the rest of the output curve looks like that of a normal typical post 1956 to 1964 wax capped organ.
Here below is a comparison between the more normal output levels of the TG notes 13 to 30, and the slightly louder levels in this region of the Bill Beer "Kansas" organ:
TG Note Normal Bill Beer "Kansas" organ
mVpp mVpp
13 15 15.55
14 14.6 17.53
15 14.3 16.40
16 14 17.53
17 13.6 16.97
18 13.3 15.84
19 13 15.55
20 12.6 13.29
21 12.3 11.88
22 12 12.44
23 11.6 11.03
24 11.3 14.71
25 11 12.44
26 11 13.29
27 11 13.57
28 11 11.31
29 11 13.29
30 11 11.03
31 11 13.01
The slightly louder levels of these TG notes in the Bill Beer "Kansas" organ might be audible enough to produce a somewhat more "ballsy" sound on the lowest two octaves of the keyboard and with more bottom end "growl" when overdriving the Leslie.
These louder than normal output levels are uneven instead of following a smoothly tapered curve so therefore this suggests the possibility that Bill Beer might have recalibrated these particular TG notes by ear whilst listening to the organ instead of trying to create a precise smoothly tapered curve.
Incidentally, I wonder if this Bill Beer "Kansas" chop organ is the same C3 organ that Steve Walsh used on the 1976 Kansas "Leftoverture" album which especially with the full drawbar settings on "Miracles out of nowhere" sounds to me more like a wax capped organ instead of a red mylar capped organ.
The Bill Beer "Kansas" organ is owned by Sam Gilman, the organist of the band "Otis Grove" and you can see and hear this organ played through a stock Leslie 145 on several Otis Grove youtube clips.
Papus wrote:
>In my experience some of those types of characters are one-trick ponies, >and the trick usually turns out to be rather mundane when finally revealed.
I would not be surprised if this is the case with the secret Bill Beer circuits.
I am purely speculating here, but I think that it would not be as necessary to hide a truly complicated or eccentric circuit because the complexity or eccentricness of the circuit would possibly dissuade others from copying it, whilst it would be much easier to copy a simple circuit thus prompting the designer to want to paranoidly hide or obfuscate the simple circuit.
As well as that, a uniquely different or innovative circuit can be patented thus legally hindering other business competitors from copying it.
Anyone who has a suitable voltage meter and who knows how to recalibrate a TG could easily measure a Bill Beer TG output curve both directly from the TG note terminal strip and also from the output of the Bill Beer solid state organ preamp, and to then recreate the Bill Beer TG output curve on another organ.
Myth wrote:
>I read it somewhere that indeed, Bill Beer had taken the best few organs, >and made notes on their TG setup. I'd too be really interested in seeing >how the TG differed with his modifications!
Many years ago Al Goff mentioned that Bill Beer recalibrated the "generator mid section" to produce "huskier mids" to complement the frequency response of Bill Beer's solid state organ preamp. Al Goff also mentioned that there were different Bill Beer output curves. He did not provide any further information.
This raises the possibility that Bill Beer might have had different output curves for different applications, for example a particular output curve intended to produce the "hot bitchin fat and ballsy" sound through a stock AO28 organ preamp, and different output curves intended to produce a similar overall sound for his solid state organ preamps, and also other different particular non standard customized TG output curves for specific organists.
========================================
END OF PART 1 OF 2
=========================================
Hi everyone.
Boyan Hristov wrote:
>Since BB changed the amplification tube circuits with transistor ones, the >path of getting that sound starts there. The organ will then sound >differently and I would recalibrate the tone generator to the levels at amp >output as in the B3 service manual which is readily available.
A member of the Hammond Zeni forum who used to own a red mylar capped Bill Beer chop organ until it died, and who still has the Bill Beer high power Leslies told me that he spoke to Bill Beer and Bill Beer told him that his goal with the solid state organ preamp and his high power solid state biamped Leslies with the JBL E140 bass speaker and the JBL 2482 treble driver was to create the sound of a good sounding organ and the tonality of a stock Leslie 122 but at much higher volume levels.
Bill Beer connected a frequency response meter near the Leslie, and he then set the TG recalibration to produce a similar response through the high power solid state Leslie as what was produced through a stock Leslie 122.
Bill Beer also said that he did not like a too trebly sound, instead he preferred a warmer sounding tonality.
Of course in reality the Bill Beer organs and Leslies do not actually sound identical to a stock organ and Leslie 122, instead they have a particular different tonality with a thicker sounding midrange which is a distinctive tonal characteristic of the JBL 2482 driver, for example Jim Pugh's red mylar capped Bill Beer chop organ and Bill Beer Leslie in this youtube clip of the Robert Cray band performing "The one in the middle"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frA3W6_Nxic
Wes wrote:
>Boyan - interesting hypothesis - that may be, in fact, how Bill arrived at >his calibration scheme. Or he may have created his own version of the >chart, by measuring an organ he felt was particularly balls.
Bill Beer mentioned in a 1991 Keyboard magazine interview that he measured the TG output curves of "six hot bitchin B3's" and that he used this as the basis for his "fat and ballsy" sounding TG output curve.
Bill Beer also mentioned that some of the later era Hammond organs did not sound as good because of their TG calibration which produced a more shrill sound.
Interestingly, as can be seen in my TG data spreadsheet which contains the measured TG output levels of over one hundred Hammond tone wheel organs spanning from all decades of production, the tonewheel generators of the pre 1956 Hammond organs were calibrated with noticeably higher output levels for the complex waveform pedal bass TG notes 1 to 12, and that the sine wave TG notes 13 to approximately 40 were calibrated slightly louder than that of the post 1956 organs.
The Hammond chief engineer Alan Young mentioned that the TG output curve was changed in 1956 "for the convenience of our test procedures".
The measured TG output curves of the pre 1956 and the post 1956 organs verify that there was a reduction to the output levels of the low frequency TG notes introduced in 1956.
Without actually having access to Bill Beer's TG output curves of the "six hot bitchin B3's", the following is my pure speculation, but with all this in mind, my speculation is that the "six hot bitchin B3s" that Bill Beer measured might possibly have been pre 1956 organs with the stronger output levels of the low frequency TG notes.
The only measured Bill Beer TG output curve in my TG data spreadsheet is that of a wax capped post 1956 B3 or C3 chop organ which was once owned by the Progressive Rock band Kansas.
In this Bill Beer organ, there are slightly louder than normal levels in the TG notes 13 to 31 range, but the rest of the output curve looks like that of a normal typical post 1956 to 1964 wax capped organ.
Here below is a comparison between the more normal output levels of the TG notes 13 to 30, and the slightly louder levels in this region of the Bill Beer "Kansas" organ:
TG Note Normal Bill Beer "Kansas" organ
mVpp mVpp
13 15 15.55
14 14.6 17.53
15 14.3 16.40
16 14 17.53
17 13.6 16.97
18 13.3 15.84
19 13 15.55
20 12.6 13.29
21 12.3 11.88
22 12 12.44
23 11.6 11.03
24 11.3 14.71
25 11 12.44
26 11 13.29
27 11 13.57
28 11 11.31
29 11 13.29
30 11 11.03
31 11 13.01
The slightly louder levels of these TG notes in the Bill Beer "Kansas" organ might be audible enough to produce a somewhat more "ballsy" sound on the lowest two octaves of the keyboard and with more bottom end "growl" when overdriving the Leslie.
These louder than normal output levels are uneven instead of following a smoothly tapered curve so therefore this suggests the possibility that Bill Beer might have recalibrated these particular TG notes by ear whilst listening to the organ instead of trying to create a precise smoothly tapered curve.
Incidentally, I wonder if this Bill Beer "Kansas" chop organ is the same C3 organ that Steve Walsh used on the 1976 Kansas "Leftoverture" album which especially with the full drawbar settings on "Miracles out of nowhere" sounds to me more like a wax capped organ instead of a red mylar capped organ.
The Bill Beer "Kansas" organ is owned by Sam Gilman, the organist of the band "Otis Grove" and you can see and hear this organ played through a stock Leslie 145 on several Otis Grove youtube clips.
Papus wrote:
>In my experience some of those types of characters are one-trick ponies, >and the trick usually turns out to be rather mundane when finally revealed.
I would not be surprised if this is the case with the secret Bill Beer circuits.
I am purely speculating here, but I think that it would not be as necessary to hide a truly complicated or eccentric circuit because the complexity or eccentricness of the circuit would possibly dissuade others from copying it, whilst it would be much easier to copy a simple circuit thus prompting the designer to want to paranoidly hide or obfuscate the simple circuit.
As well as that, a uniquely different or innovative circuit can be patented thus legally hindering other business competitors from copying it.
Anyone who has a suitable voltage meter and who knows how to recalibrate a TG could easily measure a Bill Beer TG output curve both directly from the TG note terminal strip and also from the output of the Bill Beer solid state organ preamp, and to then recreate the Bill Beer TG output curve on another organ.
Myth wrote:
>I read it somewhere that indeed, Bill Beer had taken the best few organs, >and made notes on their TG setup. I'd too be really interested in seeing >how the TG differed with his modifications!
Many years ago Al Goff mentioned that Bill Beer recalibrated the "generator mid section" to produce "huskier mids" to complement the frequency response of Bill Beer's solid state organ preamp. Al Goff also mentioned that there were different Bill Beer output curves. He did not provide any further information.
This raises the possibility that Bill Beer might have had different output curves for different applications, for example a particular output curve intended to produce the "hot bitchin fat and ballsy" sound through a stock AO28 organ preamp, and different output curves intended to produce a similar overall sound for his solid state organ preamps, and also other different particular non standard customized TG output curves for specific organists.
========================================
END OF PART 1 OF 2
Comment